I read over all the proposals and picked the ones I liked best. The criteria I used were pretty simple: I looked for projects that had a clearly defined mission, were global in scope, and looked like they might actually work as planned. I stayed away from proposals that wanted to “enable” other non profits because I find most of them to be ineffective. Here is the list in alphabetical order:
A Global Neighbor Network
This project is very ambitious, and I voted for it mainly because it is already underway. Naabus appears to have the expertise and organizational capacity to handle a project like this, and I feel that the award money would go to good use.
Farmer 2 Farmer Learning
This project has a very narrow, clear mission that is easily attainable. They also have a history of success in this area. Lastly, improving third world agriculture is a pretty serious issue.
Free Pledge
This is the one project I voted for that “enables” other non profits because I know from personal experience that they are simple and effective.
HELP Telemedicine
This is exactly the type of project that web technology should be applied to. In the coming decade internet technology is really going to penetrate the poorest parts of the planet, but proper medical expertise will be generations behind. This project can bridge that gap. My one reservation is that it may put too much emphasis on sophisticated technology that 1.needs alot of power 2.will not work properly 3.could get stolen.
The Hub
This project is my personal favorite. Its goals are extremely clear and simple, its mission is incredibly important, and it can be implemented easily and inexpensively. This is an excellent example of the way Web 2.0 technology can change the world.
The Second Road
This project has a precise, clearly attainable goal. Unfortunately, people in our society who are recovering from addiction tend to be stigmatized, so it is fully appropriate that they take to the Internet to support one another.
World’s Biggest Problems
I have to be candid. This is the project I am working on, so my endorsement of it is obviously biased. That said, we are the only organization (besides maybe the UN) that is tackling issues of this size and significance. We have a very clear vision of what we want to do, we have an 18 year history providing analysis on issues of this scope, and the project is already underway and partially funded. I would sincerely appreciate any comments/criticisms/support.
Comments
Thanks from HELP
Thank you for the encouraging words for HELP's telemedicine network proposal. I am impressed with your insight to this issue (I sometimes wonder if many even understand the tremendous impact this will have). Your concerns about security and power are also very insightful. I believe the project (you can see much more about it on our web site) addresses both of those very valid concerns.
Power: We have kept everything 12 volt with a battery array and solar recharging. Even the initial response backpack I use is self sustaining in the same way. A far greater challenge is keeping the World Health Organization (WHO) approved refrigerators (for meds) powered up. In order to receive many of the meds we need we have to abide by certain mandates to this regard. However we have even managed to take care of that as well.
Security: How great it was to hear someone have that level of insight toward concerns we are faced to deal with every day. Our Doc-in-a-Box mobile clinics are not only a great way to have a clinic brought in and made operational virtually anywhere, but they are also pretty good at being able to remain secured in many third-world applications. The way we have configured our design is that everything is taken down and locked inside when not in use, then easily reassembled the next day when opened up again.
I have witnessed many times the cause for security concerns such as those you have mentioned. You are very correct. This concern must be addressed proactively at the onset of these projects. We believe we are doing this.
One more thought:
My mentor was the former "White House Ambassador to the Hungry World" under the Regan administration and was founder of Food for the Hungry and prior to that was VP/Overseas Director for World Vision. He had over 40 years in the disaster fields of more than 70 countries. He passed away a few years ago and charged me with continuing to carry his torch (so to speak).
As he never had much in the way of communications from the disaster back here to the states, he would always be spending a lot of time and money flying back here as quickly as possible with photos and information for fundraising, acquisition of commodities and to mobilize more support teams.
He would have done back-flips to see this new technology that enables us to communicate to our constituency directly from the disaster site, be able to bring advanced medicine to areas where normally you just watch many die, and even provide direct video/audio feeds to the media, without ever needing to leave the disaster.
This is good stuff. When I say this will save lives that is not marketing hype, we really will be able to make a huge difference with this.
Thank you again for your supportive words. We really hope we can obtain support for this.
Randy Roberson - Disaster Logistics
H.E.L.P.
rroberson@disasterlogistics.org
www.disasterlogistics.org
Tele-Medicine "New Independence New Abilities"
Hello Randy,
Indeed, it's great to know that someone else is also providing Tele-Medicine as a way of reaching out to far flung areas. I also am working on something similar, in the context of preventing disabilities, promoting awareness about disabilities, providing Tele-Medicine in the remote areas in India. I would appreciate if you could take some time to go through my proposal "New Independence New Abilities" dedicated for People with Disabilities. Tele-Medicine is one of the components. We are a fairly new company and look towards any guidance and assistance that wise, knowledgeable, and experienced people like yourself can provide us.
I look forward to your kind and generous support/guidance/assistance.
Thank you.
In the Spirit of Humanity,
Nina
Hi Nina,
I took a brief glance at your project proposal, looking for how you were planning to integrate telemedicine into your efforts. Perhaps I didn't look long enough because I didn't get a clear picture in my minds eye of what benefit specifically you were looking for.My apologies for being brief, I have an appointment in a few minutes I am rushing to meet.
I see you spent time with Mother Theresa. My mentor was a long time friend to Mother Theresa (Dr. Larry Ward) and I also spent time working on the streets just outside her "Home for the Destitute Dying" and with many of the more than 3 million "Street People" in Calcutta. It was there I first realized this was what I what I was meant to do.
As for telemedicine and how my organization could help... I am very open to the idea of exploring that. I plan to be back in India (slightly south in the Andhra Pradesh province) a little later this year and could easily - and gladly - revisit Calcutta at the same time.
I am also working to assemble a telemedicine network throughout much of rural India. Again, I'm not sure what specific benefits you were hoping to bring to those whom you are concerned about and I'm not sure specifically where they are located. But please know I will be happy to explore ways in which we could help you help others. That is what we do.
Much like any and all of our other projects in various locations in India and around the world, we always need to see the project first. I'm sure you know there are many people who make appeals for assistance and the money never gets to its intended destination. As such we always confirm the viability of operations, mandate sound feduciary accountability and - through the use of the telemedicine/teleconferencing connections (and periodic personal visits) review the ongoing effectiveness of the projects we support. It just makes sense as we endeavor to be good stewards of the monies entrusted to us.
This is only mentioned to lay a groundwork of understanding for what may become a wonderful possible collaborative effort in meeting the needs in Calcutta (a very special place to me indeed).
Thank you for thinking of us. I look forward to taking this conversation to the next level.
Randy Roberson - Disaster Logistics
H.E.L.P.
rroberson@disasterlogistics.org
www.disasterlogistics.org
Tele-Medicine "New Independence New Abilities"
Dear Randy,
Thank you for taking time out of your busy schedule to go through my project. I have read both your responses.
I am sorry to note that you have certain doubts, the numbers re: for an amubulance have been quoted, so are correct, but I would be interested to know from you, your quotes for this Ambulance equipped with Tele-Medicine, regarding "other ideas" which ones do not pass the reasonableness test, I would be most interested to learn your viewpoint, since my "ideas" have been researched in today's technological market? I know that such a Rehab Facility in India, would be a great success, because I have done my homework. Of course, the Vision is Big, that is the reason, I have planned the process in Phases.
As far as Mother Teresa is concerned, I was a student, and as such volunteered through my school, and worked with her, specially assisting the poor villagers in the areas of hygiene, and education. She taught me a lot, and laid a foundation for me for keeping my interest always alive in helping people from various walks of life. My own grandfather was a doctor, and a great humanitarian, (was honored for his Humanitarian work by the President of India, Dr. Krishnan) he was also instrumental in my education/awareness/exposure to the needy. Therefore, I have kept this flame lit, and gathered as much experience as possible, I know that I have made a difference in some people's lives. I have also worked with young girls, who were abused, raped, and ran away from their homes, to become prostitutes. This experience was a real eye opener for me, since these girls were just kids, hurt inside, and we had to convince them and guide them through the process of changing their lives around. I can relate to you many such experiences. But I have chosen now, to dedicate the rest of my life to The People with Disabilities, since this hits home, is personal, and has been a journey. Through this experience, I have learnt the difficulties, the issues, the abuse, the break-up of lives, and families, the disruption, and the total devastation that the People with Disabilities have to face and endure every minute of every day. Disabilities are unknown by the general public and quite often misunderstood, even here is the western world as well, so I know what the conditions are in India!!. The families of the disabled are always affected, and they are overlooked, and thus the cycle of disharmony and discontent begins, and the blame ends up in the lap of the disabled, who then suffers in silence, and on and on it goes. Many homes, marriages, families are broken up, the income coming in the house decreases, poverty starts to creep in, homelessness, suicide and other such misfortunes start occuring. It is so very important that the awareness of People with Disabilities should take place on a regular manner. Today, there are so many new technologies and new products, programs out, that if we can provide these to these people, train them, in other words Rehabilitate them to their equitable level, so many problems will end. As Mother Teresa said "Everybody today seems to be in such a terrible rush, anxious for greater developments and greater riches and so on, so that children have very little time for their parents. Parents have very little time for each other and in the home begins the disruption of peace of the world." Mother Teresa taught me that Love, Peace, Service with Love, represent God. Have Faith in God, and keep on doing your good deeds. I remember the first time I saw her with a Leper, that really was a lesson in Faith for me. I saw God in Action. As far as the quotes of Mother Teresa are concerned, I have used them to the best of my ability to emphasis the relationship to the issue. Sometimes, we can say or write as much as we want, and yet, there is a perfect quote that says it all. She didn't care if the person was disabled or had an infectious disease, she treated them equally with her loving touch.
I am trying my best, and as we all know, every journey is a learning journey, where we will be always learning from our errors, and thus coming up with solutions as well. I hope that I never stop learning, and I know there will be mentors coming to me to gently guide and educate me, so that I can serve better and better. We are here to make changes in the lives of People with Disabilities, regardless of age, color, religion, caste, class, gender, etc. I know that in today's world of Technology, we can Enable, Empower, Educate, and Improve the quality of their lives. Rehabilitation = Recovery which Enables the disabled to live out their lives productively, independently, and with dignity, and be treated as an equitable Person.
Randy, I hope the above clarifies and answers your questions. I sincerely hope that we can connect up together, so that we can share our knowledge and resources, and change the quality of the lives of the People we serve.
Thank you, again Randy.
In the Spirit of Humanity,
Nina
Sorry Nina...
I went back (couldn't resist) and looked at your proposal a bit more. The numbers you are quoting for an ambulance in India are exceedingly - in a word - off.
Likewise some of the other ideas you have do not pass the reasonableness test. I also find it very difficult to believe you worked with Mother Theresa as you are constantly making statements that really quite contradict her stance on various issues.
Your heart may be in the right place, but some of your planning needs to play catch up.
Sorry to be so blunt. But as you will remember - if indeed you worked with her - Mother Theresa would have been also.
Randy Roberson - Disaster Logistics
H.E.L.P.
Telemedicine
Randy, I really like your project and I think you can certainly reach your goals. I had an idea I wanted to run by you that came to me after I worked in rural Cambodia.
Someone should develope a basic 4 month medical training program that is simple enough that any literate person anywhere in the world can learn it. There should also be a 2 month region-specific training course afterwards. Then, the graduates could return to their communities and prevent alot of unneccesary deaths. This seems alot more effective than having either fully qualified doctors or nothing.
Good luck with your project,
Paul
Your idea has potential!
I like the concept. That could also be easily rolled out from one of our clinics to extend its effectiveness further. Makes sense. We should talk. I am also headed to the central highlands of Vietnam in October and will be in and out of the Philippines this year. That idea has some significant potential!
Randy Roberson - Disaster Logistics
H.E.L.P.
rroberson@disasterlogistics.org
www.disasterlogistics.org
Randy, I noticed on your
Randy,
I noticed on your list of top 6 projects you were open to lobbying, so allow me to be a little self serving for the moment.
Please check out our idea here: World's Biggest Problems
I think alot of people arent really getting what we are doing. I have a few ideas as to why, but I dont want to put thoughts in your head before you have a chance to see for yourself. Please take a few minutes to read our proposal and let me know how it hits you. Feel free to be as critical as you want, I have thick skin.
Thanks, Paul
Interesting!
I love the idea of anything that brings minds together to meet a challenge, especially the ones you mention in your project proposal.
Please pardon me however if I seem a little dim on this one. I like the basic concept, but I'm not sure I completely understand the whole process you envision. This is probably just due to me thinking in more simplistic terms than perhaps you do. As such I think I would need to talk with you for a bit to more fully understand what you want to achieve.
As for offering you a critical eye on this...
Your sustainability doesn't really show sustainability as much as it shows what you believe your hard costs to be. I think it may be better to see how - once operational - you believe this will sustain itself.
The only other criticism I could see is that I have found only a few people wanting to cover salaries while many more are interested in helping to support the assembly of a project infrastructure. I think you would have a better chance to get people to help you with the salary needs if you can show a way the project will sustain itself over the long haul.
I would very much like to talk with you more about this. The concept is very interesting. I think the biggest problem here is just my own understanding, rather than your project.
Randy Roberson - Disaster Logistics
H.E.L.P.
rroberson@disasterlogistics.org
www.disasterlogistics.org