NetSquared enables social benefit organizations to leverage the tools of the social web.

Blogs

Hot Spot

NetSquared teaming up with Sun Microsystems to produce global Hack Days. First stop, San Paolo, Brazil on October 1, 2008. Next up, China! Register: Collaborate for Change.

NetSquared is excited to announce the launch of a New Submission Form and a new Project Gallery as we plan for upcoming Partner Challenges. To Participate please Register, Login and submit a Project.

N2Y2Con: Portals?

I've heard the term "portal" used several times this morning? Are we regressing? Did nonprofits miss the "portal" boat in the 1990's and now feel compelled to re-vist the failed experiment?

What gives?

Erica Rios works at http://www.anitaborg.org. She also blogs at http://www.xicanista.net/blogs

Technorati:

Comments

Portals? No! Open Information

After mulling it over a bit more I am thinking that the use of the word "portal" implies an old technology approach - collecting links to other sites. That means static, frequently broken and difficult to maintain content.

Thinking about how the term was thrown around yesterday, I am guessing there is a greater interest in making information more:

  1. open
  2. easier to find
  3. easier to apply

"Portals" were unsuccessful in achieving these goals. So here are some ideas I have:

Making Information Open
Create content! Implement a simple technology and spend a majority of your time soliciting content from individuals that are already finding success.

Easier to find
Get technical support on optomizing search results for issues related to your topic. Also investigate how you can leverage tagging to assist people in finding your content.

Moreover, if your target audiences are not tech savvy, it is likely helpful to get back to the basics. Use grassroots social change strategies to educate your audiences on how they can use your website, or perhaps the web more generally.

Easier to Apply
This is where the rubber hits the road. My view of human nature is there are some people that will read something and it will cause them to act immediately. These type of people are far and few between. However, a majority of people with only a reasonable amount of support will act if they understand the value of their actions to their immediate circumstance or that of their communities. Given the messiness of human nature, I am thinking this is where the interesting technical and social change questions are unearthed. This is the place of experimentation and social and technical innovation.

Erica Rios
Anita Borg Institute for Women and Technology
http://www.anitaborg.org
http://www.xicanista.net

A clarification

Since I think I used the word in my presentation, I want to clarify: I was using the word "portal" in a more expansive way. Perhaps it was an inapt word choice, but I simply meant a coordinated, accessible destination for a particular project -- in this case, anti-genocide activism.

Let me know if this has made things less clear...

Portal definition

What you described is my basic understanding of what a portal is. The wikipedia definition of portal seems consistent as well.

We need more differentiation. If not a portal, then what is it?

Erica Rios
Anita Borg Institute for Women and Technology
http://www.anitaborg.org
http://www.xicanista.net

Old-timey thinking

I think you're getting an accurate assessment of the range of "forward-thinking" vs. "old-timey thinking" in the non-profit and NGO community.

Sometimes people just need to be caught up; however, there are undoubtedly others who have people they connect with professionally that still think that the web is a bunch of tubes, and you can't leapfrog organizational learning when people already have some ideas about the technology, you have to uplift.

Also the non-profit world, since growing topline is always a big question mark, they can become very risk averse, and view everything "new" in the sense of "unproven" rather than "exciting and full of potential."

Search over took the Portal Boat

So is this an issue of education? With the advent of quality search results portals are no longer needed. Search supplemented with tags can find you rich results.

Do we (the nonprofit sector) need to get together and train on how to use search and tagging to find one another. The world is messy and thus so is the web - That's why the portal thing didn't work and likely won't work again.

Does CompuMentor or TechSoup do trainings like this? If not, who does?

Erica Rios
Anita Borg Institute for Women and Technology
http://www.anitaborg.org
http://www.xicanista.net

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Subscribe to Net2News

Sign up for NetSquared's e-newsletter

Latest Comments

User login



Sitemap

About

Share

Projects

Challenges

Partner