NetSquared enables social benefit organizations to leverage the tools of the social web.

net2 updates

Building community in your area? Check out the newly-launched Community Organizers Handbook! Everything you need to start and grow a NetSquared Local group or any other community-powered program.

net2 local

NetSquared Local events provide a chance to connect locally with all those interested in the intersection of social technologies and social change. There are new groups forming every week: Join in!

net2 updates

Building community in your area? Check out the newly-launched Community Organizers Handbook! Everything you need to start and grow a NetSquared Local group or any other community-powered program.

Aegis MX - Voice Database to Stop State-Sponsored Violence

Challenges Entered: 

VoIP technologies such as Skype have reduced the cost of communication but they offer the additional benefit of being able to aggregate call data and voicemail into a central repository through specialized application programming interfaces(APIs). As such, this project will be a third-party application that routes messages sent to a local Skype number to a database, accessible to human rights organizations worldwide.

 By initially relying upon voice, this project can sidestep issues of technical capacity and/or literacy, allowing faster deployment and easier adoption. Callers would be able to use a familiar interface indistinguishable from most voicemail systems. Because Skype offers the ability to set up a local telephone number in Mexico, anyone with a cell phone would be able to call without incurring significant cost.

The goal would be to connect activists under threat with human rights organizations able to provide support through intervention or investigation. Voicemail sent to this database will automatically be tagged with date, time and receiving number(where available, and users should be given option to remain anonymous). Accessible by representatives of human rights groups, voicemail could be augmented with keywords, notes, location data and follow up information. Any of this additional information has the potential to be useful in an investigation or building a case to bring to authorities.

 A typical usage might proceed as follows:

  • Activist has received threats in the past for her activities.
  • Activist notices an unfamiliar vehicle parked across the street from her workplace. Inside are three men wearing uniforms who are watching her. One even smiles.
  • She calls the local number for this system and leaves a message describing the men, the vehicle, the scene and requests that somebody calls her back.
  • This message arrives in the database; subscribed users are alerted.
  • A member of an international NGO working in the area listens to the message, tags it with license plate number, street name and other information within the message. She places a call back to the activist, advising her to proceed to their local office.
  • A member of a different NGO is browsing the database and notices a match on the license plate, which had been reported a year before in a nearby town where an activist had disappeared. He suspects that the same people are involved and links them together.
  • Six months later, a petition is filed with the Inter-American Court of Human Rights. In the petition, attorneys use these voicemails as evidence suggesting a widespread pattern of harassment, claiming also that government vehicles were involved in a number of cases.

Lack of action or complicity by local, regional or federal authorities makes cases of harassment and disappearance such as these a human rights issue, rather than simply a criminal or civil complaint. As a signatory to the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights, the American Convention on Human Rights and the Inter-American Convention on the Forced Disappearance of Persons - among other instruments - Mexico has legally binding treaty obligations to prevent the types of violations described above. Failure to prevent these types of violations constitute a breach of an individual's right to freely associate, communicate and live free from arbitrary detention or arrest. Further, as a breach of international law they present a liability for the Mexican state.

By providing the tools necesary to collect and disseminate evidence among interested parties, this tool will allow local activists, international human rights groups and state officials to harmonize their interests by intervening and investigating claims.

 This project is not meant to single out Mexico - which has made considerable strides in its protection of human rights in recent years - but to provide a test case and proof of concept which could later be replicated in other areas and for different populations. Because this project relies on lightweight and widely available mobile technologies such as voice it has the ability to scale easily to cover a variety of situations worldwide. Choosing to limit the project's initial scope will allow for rapid testing and quicker feedback by all users.

 Additional Notes For Future Versions:

  • Harassment of activists often begins with phone calls or text message; future versions may allow such calls to be automatically routed to the database as a "honeypot" feature.
  • While the scope of this project deals only with voice information, there is no reason why the system could not be adapted to handle images, video, text or GPS data.
  • Given adequate locational data, alerts could be rebroadcast to individuals in the immediate area, who could "flashmob" the area and collect more information.
  • As noted below, privacy issues will need to be addressed at every step of the program. Safety of callers is paramount and it is critical that this tool in no way jeopardizes that safety.
Project Assessment
Financial support: 
No
Sustainability Model: 
None yet established, but there are a number of options.
Expertise needed: 
Policy/Program Expertise: <p>In order to better target this project to the needs of the user, it would be helpful to have input from groups working in this geographical area and who have experience dealing with these types of issues. By drawing on this experience, it would be possible to make sure that all included features support the goals of the local and international groups that it is intended to serve.</p><p>Also, it would help to incorporate best practices regarding privacy, information-sharing, ethical standards and evidentiary procedures.</p>
Technical Expertise: It would be useful to consult with a software developer who has specific experience working with the Skype API, and would be able to suggest the most robust and cost-effective manner of proceeding with this project.
Identified Obstacles: 
Issues of confidentiality and information security would need to be addressed, callers would need to be assured that information that they provide will be treated as the privileged data that it is. Initially, data collected would be protected, shared only among authorized users. Once privacy impacts are assessed and addressed, future versions might have the option of making pieces of information public as part of a larger campaign.

Careful Marketing

I like the idea of using pre-existing, virtually off-the-shelf systems. A key element, as with most of the projects here, is careful and creative marketing to activists...especially early adopters when any positive impacts of the system are months away.   The timeliness of the human rights rep response to the initial phone call is a critical incentive.

An additional consideration is how to prevent and/or screen false reports -- especially those that generate from threatenting entity.

Simple, easy to use, and filling a need -- totally fundable. Nice job.  

Early Adopters

I think that off-the-shelf products make a project like this easier to get running. This project is based on the principle of not reinventing the wheel. The technical tasks are not where the innovation will be found, rather it will be found in the users and the networks that the users are embedded in. Innovation occurs at a deep level of social interaction, and not on the technical level, necessarily.

Which you allude to. Part of the reason why this project is submitted to Netsquared is because it allows for a wider range of exposure to early adopters than might be found in my own network. The real work is to understand their needs and make the technology serve those needs.  

Screening false reports will also need to be addressed. Once the beta version is out there, we can do some tests to discover how the system would be compromised by false reporting.  

 Thank you, and we look forward to more feedback!

The issue of trust and confidentiality

I like the idea of voicemail + database with a web interface that NGOs can access.   One danger is that the opposition could possibly also gain access to this data. Therefore, I suggest some security assurances would have to be in place for people to 'trust' this system.   I know you mention caller safety in the 'future versions' list of notes, but I think this should be front and center or people that are scared may avoid using any system that keeps records.

As far as financing, I can imagine there are human rights foundations that would be interested in funding this project. Perhaps evidence collected could result in lawsuits and fines or settlements that would also help to sustain the project.

Privacy is Key

Great points, Dan. While I have considered it, you are probably right in pointing out that privacy should play a more central role in the early stages of development. I can imagine that without guarantees of confidentiality adoption might be hobbled. I wonder what kind of assurances would lend credibility to security efforts? My hope is that we can learn more at the conference.

User login

Sitemap